is reader-supported. When you buy something through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases

Can You Freeze Pimento Cheese? (Step by Step Guide)

Pimento cheese can be quite a game-changer! Originating from the Southern United States, pimento cheese has become one of everyone’s favorite cheese spread or dip over the years. Best part? It is super versatile!

Be it a spread for your crackers, a dip for your veggies or in your sandwich, or even slices of it in salads or soups, pimento cheese is a real treat. If you have too much pimento cheese at home, we don’t blame you; it is quite delicious! We are here to help you with storing it long enough for you to enjoy it later on. 

Can you freeze pimento cheese?

Yes, you absolutely can! Pimento cheese has a great shelf life. However, you might notice slight textural changes, nevertheless, it is safe to freeze. You can leave it in the freezer and not worry about it spoiling for up to 3 months! It may need a little stirring when you thaw if the cheese separates or hardens, but it’s worth it!

Freezing pimento cheese is not that much of a task, but it is important to know how to do it the right way. In this article, we are going to discuss how you can safely freeze pimento cheese and thaw it when you need it as well. Continue reading to know more! 

How to Freeze Pimento Cheese

Allow us to take you through our step-by-step guide to freezing pimento cheese:

Step 1: Take the cheese out and pack it tightly with some plastic wrap. Securing the cheese properly will help maintain its integrity while it freezes. 

Step 2: Place your packed cheese either in airtight containers or sealable freezer bags. Make sure to remove all the air before you secure the container or bags as an extra precaution. It reduces the risk of your cheese getting oxidized and suffering freezer burns. 

Step 3: The final step is to simply pop it in the freezer. We recommend you note down the date of freezing on your package as well. This way, you will know how much longer your cheese is going to stay fresh. Pimento cheese stays fresh for up to 3 months of freezing. 

If you are storing a large quantity of pimento cheese, you should separate them into portions before packing them and sticking them in the freezer. 

Note: After taking your pimento cheese out of the freezer, you may notice that a certain texture on its surface. The cheese may appear grainier and dry in comparison to its original creamy, smooth texture. All you need to do is give it a good stir before having it ready for your meal. If you are planning to use it as a dip, blending the cheese is a good option as well. If required, add a sufficient amount of water, and process it to retain the creamy, smooth texture. 

Honestly, this is a great plus with freezing pimento cheese. The only changes you may observe are textural changes. As long as it is stored properly, you will hardly find a change in its original taste. 

Recommended reading of other Freezing FAQs:

How to Thaw Pimento Cheese

Now that you know how to freeze pimento cheese, let’s look at how to thaw it:

Transfer the pimento cheese from the freezer to the refrigerator. Let it sit there overnight to allow it to thaw. This will give your cheese enough time to defrost gradually. Please make sure not to stick your cheese in the microwave or in a pan to defrost it.

Even though it is faster, you could damage its texture and cause the mayonnaise to separate because of the sudden hit. You may not have any other option but to throw it away.

If you don’t want to thaw the whole portion of pimento cheese, just take out the quantity you need for the day. You can then place these portions in the refrigerator to let them thaw. We recommend doing this because regardless of whether refreezing is okay as it is not as good as the first. 

You can toss your cheese on a pan to heat it only after it is finished thawing. You can turn the stove to medium-low heat and slowly cook it to have it ready to eat! 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can you freeze homemade pimento cheese?

Yes, you can freeze homemade pimento cheese. Freezing pimento cheese for a certain duration may also come with certain changes in texture. If you don’t mind this, you can comfortably go ahead and pop it in your freezer. One thing you need not worry about is how it is going to taste. On proper freezing, you will hardly notice any changes in the taste. So, after thawing the cheese, all you need to do is correct the texture. 

Recommended reading of other Freezing FAQs:

Can you freeze palmetto pimento cheese?

Well, while palmetto pimento cheese is safe to freeze, it is essential to know that you may observe some changes in it. First, you are most likely to notice a dry, grainy layer on the outer surface. You may also see the oils from the mayo starting to separate from it. Solid and semi-solid cheeses are relatively safer to freeze and are easy to correct after thawing as well. It is best to avoid freezing spreads and dips of the same cheese. 

Can you freeze pimento cheese dip?

Well, pimento cheese dip isn’t always the best food item for the freezer. Dairy products aren’t very good for the freezer. Their texture and taste may alter on prolonged duration in the freezer. Still, when prepped correctly, you can have it freezer ready.

Can you freeze pimento cheese sandwiches?

It is best to store solid or semi-solid cheese in the freezer as its composition is more suitable for it. On the other hand, spreads and dips do not freeze as well. There is a good chance the oils may separate from the mayonnaise on freezing. So, we don’t advise you to store pimento cheese sandwiches. 

Can you freeze pimento cheese sausage balls?

Yes, you can freeze pimento cheese sausage balls. Once you cook them, please wait to bring them down to room temperature before packing them in the freezer. Please make sure you haven’t left the cheese sausage balls out on the counter too long. You will greatly be reducing the risk of any potential bacterial growth.

You can freeze pimento cheese sausage balls before cooking them as well. Uncooked pimento cheese balls stay good in the freezer for up to 4 months. First, line some parchment paper on a baking tray and let them sit in the freezer for a couple of hours. Once they turn solid, you can take them out of the freezer and pack them in airtight containers or sealable freezer bags. They only take about 15 to 20 minutes to thaw. So, you can have them ready real quick whenever you crave it!  

Can you freeze the pimento cheese spread?

Freezing pimento cheese spread may not be the best option. We don’t recommend freezing pimento cheese spread because oils may separate and alter its quality. Hard and partially hard cheeses that have high fat and low moisture content are the ones that you can safely freeze. So, it is best to keep pimento cheese spread out of the freezer.


Now that you know pimento cheese is safe for the freezer, nothing is stopping you from keeping some at hand! You can comfortably freeze this cheese for three months without worrying that it will turn bad. 

Let it be a lazy day on your coach or for a party you’re throwing; pimento cheese is a real treat! It’s great when you can use one item for so many different things.

Pimento cheese can a spread for sandwiches, a dip for your chips, or even for a French cheese board; it really is a winner!

Although freezing and thawing seem too simple of a task to pay much attention to, it is crucial to do it properly. It determines how well your cheese freezes and tastes after you thaw it. 

It is worth going the extra mile because of how versatile it is. You can add it in pretty much anything to jazz up the flavors!

We hope our article helped you understand more about freezing and thawing pimento cheese! Happy freezing!